Second Circuit Ruling Leaves Kalshi and Coinbase Facing State Sports Betting Cases

Nov 09, 2026 934 views

The Second Circuit has left New York and Connecticut free to pursue state cases against Kalshi and Coinbase while the companies appeal. For prediction market operators, the ruling weakens an immediate effort to keep state enforcement on hold while they argue that sports event contracts belong under federal commodities law. The dispute is now developing along two tracks: state gambling cases can proceed, while the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) presses its own claims that federal law controls. That split may eventually draw the Supreme Court into a fight over who gets to regulate these contracts.

The panel denied both companies’ requests for injunctions pending appeal, finding they hadn’t met the standard for interim relief. It didn’t explain which part of that standard they failed to satisfy, so the order offers little guidance about how the judges weighed the competing arguments. The decision followed oral arguments involving Kalshi, Coinbase, the CFTC, New York and Connecticut. For now, the practical effect is clearer than the reasoning: the states can keep litigating while the appeals continue.

State cases can proceed

New York and Connecticut can continue trying to take the companies’ sports event contracts offline under state gambling laws. Gaming attorney Daniel Wallach described the ruling as a major win for both states. He said a remand order could return the cases to state court, where the states could seek preliminary injunctions. That would give them another route to pursue restrictions while the broader legal dispute remains unresolved.

Kalshi has already been denied preliminary relief by federal courts in both states: in New York in July and Connecticut in August. Those decisions matter because they show that the companies have struggled to secure temporary protection at more than one stage of the litigation. They don’t settle the underlying question of whether federal commodities law displaces state gambling rules, but they leave the states with room to continue their cases in the meantime.

New York sued KalshiEX on July 31, 2026, alleging that its prediction market operated as illegal gambling. In April 2026, Attorney General Letitia James also sued Coinbase and Gemini on similar grounds. The New York case against Kalshi seeks billions of dollars in damages, according to InGame. That claim raises the stakes for the company beyond the immediate question of whether particular contracts can remain available: the state is also seeking a substantial financial remedy.

Connecticut’s enforcement effort began earlier. In December 2025, the state’s Gaming Division ordered Kalshi and two other sites to stop offering unlicensed online sports wagering. On August 26, 2026, Attorney General William Tong, Consumer Protection Commissioner Bryan T. Cafferelli and Gov. Ned Lamont announced a lawsuit seeking to stop Kalshi from offering sports wagers in the state. The sequence shows that the state’s position has moved from an administrative order to a court fight, where the parties can contest how the contracts should be classified.

A split over who regulates event contracts

The Second Circuit ruling adds to a series of decisions against Kalshi, Coinbase or the CFTC in efforts to block state enforcement. Wallach said nine federal judicial rulings within the circuit had denied emergency or preliminary relief in those efforts. The tally describes outcomes on requests for temporary protection; it doesn’t by itself answer the central legal question about which level of government has authority over sports event contracts. Still, repeated denials make it harder for the companies and the CFTC to pause state action while that question is litigated.

The outcome also conflicts with the Third Circuit’s decision that New Jersey can’t regulate sports bets offered through prediction markets. The difference gives each side a substantial appellate ruling to point to, but it also leaves operators facing different legal conditions depending on where they do business. This is more significant than it looks: a dispute over contract classification can determine whether a product is treated as a federally supervised market instrument or as sports wagering subject to state rules.

The CFTC is pursuing its own federal cases against states. It sued Arizona, Connecticut and Illinois on April 2, 2026, and New York on April 24. In the New York case, the agency asked a federal court to declare that federal law gives it exclusive authority over event contracts and to bar the state from enforcing laws it considers preempted. Those cases put the same jurisdictional conflict in front of federal courts from the agency’s side: the CFTC is seeking a ruling that would limit state enforcement, even as the states pursue their own claims against operators.

Why the next rulings matter

The dispute affects both state sportsbook markets and the scope of CFTC authority. If courts accept the states’ view, prediction market operators could face state gambling restrictions on sports contracts even when they argue that federal rules govern their products. If courts accept the CFTC’s position, states could have less room to apply their gambling laws to event contracts. The present rulings haven’t resolved that divide, and the denial of interim relief leaves the parties to keep fighting without a uniform answer.

New Jersey has petitioned the Supreme Court to review the Third Circuit’s April 6, 2026, decision in case 25-1922; Kalshi is preparing its response. That case could give the court an opportunity to address the growing divide over state oversight of prediction market contracts, though a petition alone doesn’t guarantee review or a broad ruling. If you’re working in this space, the immediate practical question is where state enforcement can proceed while appeals unfold. The longer-term question is whether federal commodities law leaves states any meaningful role in policing sports event contracts.

Here’s the thing: an appellate split can keep uncertainty alive well beyond any single company’s case. Operators may have to plan around different state positions while courts decide whether the same kind of contract falls within federal or state authority (and this is the part most people overlook). For now, the companies have lost a bid to pause two state cases. That’s the near-term reality.

Source: ReadWrite Editor · readwrite.com

Comments

Sign in to comment.
No comments yet. Be the first to comment.

Related Articles

Second Circuit denies Kalshi and Coinbase interim relief ...